Breaking News
skip to Main Content

One Hundred and Two Million on the Books, Forty-Two on the Market

PROVEN paid about J$11.7 billion for 20% of JMMB Group. Its 2026 annual report carries the stake at US$102.2 million; the stock market valued it at US$42.3 million. KPMG says it checked management’s cash-flow valuations against market capitalisation, but not what it found. A BATV deep dive into an annual report that also re-labels last year’s operating profit and raises the manager’s fee in a loss year.

PROVEN Group Limited published its 2026 annual report this week, a month before its annual general meeting (AGM) on 5 November in Rodney Bay, Saint Lucia. The audited numbers inside it are not new. KPMG signed the consolidated statements on 28 August 2026, and BATV has already examined the group’s geographic and segment results in Five Flags, One Engine. What is new is everything wrapped around those statements: the auditor’s report, the Directors’ Report, the Chairman’s Report, Management’s Discussion and Analysis (MD&A), the governance pages and the Ten-Year Statistical Review. This report reads those pages against the numbers.

The largest number in the story is not in the income statement. PROVEN owns 20% of JMMB Group Limited, bought in 2018 and 2019 for about J$11.7 billion. At 31 March 2026 PROVEN carried that stake in its accounts at US$102.2 million. The stock market valued it at US$42.3 million on the same day — a figure PROVEN itself discloses. Its auditor, KPMG, made the valuation a key audit matter and says it compared the discounted cash flows behind management’s valuations with the associates’ market capitalisation, where applicable. Neither KPMG nor PROVEN says what that comparison showed. Together with Access Financial Services, PROVEN’s two listed associates are carried US$68.0 million above market, a sum equal to 64.5% of the equity attributable to PROVEN’s shareholders. It is not the first time the stake’s value has been revisited: in its FY2024 report PROVEN restated its associates down by US$36.8 million, which left JMMB’s book value within about US$0.5 million of its market value. Since then the gap has reopened.

The year itself was a loss. PROVEN lost US$5.3 million, of which US$4.8 million fell on its own shareholders, against a profit of US$2.5 million for shareholders the year before. Three further findings stand out. The group’s operating profit for FY2025 was US$289,000 in last year’s annual report and US$14.75 million in this one, because US$14.5 million of finance cost was moved below the operating line without an explanatory note. The fee paid to PROVEN Management Limited (PML), the company that runs the group, rose 27.5% to US$2.3 million in the loss year. And the narrative pages disagree with each other, and with the statements, on equity, asset growth, directors’ pay and the dividend.

Except for the history of the JMMB investment in Section 2, which draws on PROVEN’s annual reports for 2020 to 2024, Jamaica Stock Exchange (JSE) notices, JMMB’s own disclosures and press reports listed under Sources, every figure comes from the annual report PROVEN has sent its shareholders, or is calculated from it. Calculations are marked as BATV’s own.

AT A GLANCE

At a Glance. The year ended 31 March 2026 in eight numbers. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

MASTER CHART

Master chart. PROVEN’s 20% stake in JMMB Group: what was paid (BATV calculation at historical exchange rates), the carrying amount, management’s value in use, the stock market value at 31 March 2026, and dividends received to March 2026 (BATV calculation). Sources: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 13; NCB Financial Group release, 27 December 2018; JMMB APO and dividend notices; BATV analysis.

PROVEN Place, Kingston. Photo: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report.

1. The year in one line

The income statement can be read in a sentence: the businesses produced an operating profit of US$10.6 million, and the cost of the money that funds them was US$17.4 million. Everything else is detail. The share of profits from associates — JMMB and Access — fell by half to US$2.5 million, tax took US$1.0 million, and the group closed at a loss of US$5.3 million. The minority shareholders of Roberts Manufacturing absorbed US$461,000 of it, leaving US$4.8 million, or 0.6 US cents a share, for PROVEN’s owners.

Table 1. Consolidated income statement, US$’000

LineFY2026FY2025Change
Net interest income30,87030,675+0.6%
Gross profit, manufacturing16,51118,462−10.6%
Gross profit, property sales3,426(963)n/m
Fees and commissions9,04610,571−14.4%
Net fair value and realised gains4,8021,256+282%
Foreign exchange, pension, rental and other income9,3739,923−5.5%
Operating revenue, net74,02869,924+5.9%
Operating expenses(63,393)(55,174)+14.9%
Operating profit (new definition)10,63514,750−27.9%
Finance cost(17,386)(14,461)+20.2%
Preference share dividend (manager’s carry)–(260)n/m
Share of profit of associates2,5065,193−51.7%
(Loss)/profit before tax(4,245)5,222n/m
Income tax(1,036)(447)+131.8%
(Loss)/profit for the year(5,281)4,775n/m
Attributable to owners of PROVEN(4,820)2,503n/m

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, consolidated statement of profit or loss (page 79). Grouping of the smaller income lines and percentage changes are BATV calculations.

Revenue grew; costs grew faster. Operating expenses rose 14.9% to US$63.4 million. The MD&A attributes the increase to higher legal and professional fees, a US$1.3 million software write-off and a US$1.3 million goodwill impairment. Note 30 shows the scale of the first item: legal and other professional fees rose from US$3.5 million to US$6.6 million, an increase of 86%. Salaries, wages and related costs rose 17.8% to US$21.0 million, partly offset by lower bonuses.

Exhibit E01. From operating profit to the loss attributable to owners, FY2026. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

2. One hundred and two million on the books, forty-two on the market

WHAT THE ACCOUNTS SHOW

PROVEN owns 20% of JMMB Group Limited and 24.72% of Access Financial Services Limited, both listed on the JSE. Under the equity method the stakes are carried at cost, plus PROVEN’s share of their profits and other comprehensive income, less dividends received and any impairment. At 31 March 2026 that carrying amount was US$117.6 million. Note 13 of the annual report discloses what the market thought they were worth on the same day: US$42.3 million for JMMB and US$7.3 million for Access, a total of US$49.6 million.

Table 2. Associates: carrying amount, market value and value in use at 31 March 2026, US$’000

MeasureJMMB GroupAccess FinancialTotal
Carrying amount in the accounts102,15215,454117,606
Market (fair) value disclosed42,2977,31749,614
Carrying amount above market value59,8558,13767,992
Recoverable amount (value in use)119,15517,589136,744
Headroom over carrying amount17,0032,13519,138
Market value a year earlier51,5687,12558,693
Discount rate used (prior year)14.42% (17.38%)24.1% (23.3%) 
Terminal multiple used (prior year)7.7x (15.8x)4.98x (4.0x) 

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 13. Differences and headroom are BATV calculations.

The US$68.0 million gap is 64.5% of PROVEN’s attributable equity of US$105.4 million. The two associates alone are carried at more than the whole of the equity attributable to PROVEN’s shareholders. At the average share price for the year, US$0.10, the market valued all of PROVEN at roughly US$80 million (BATV calculation: 801.7 million shares), less than the book value of its two associates. The gap is not new: a year earlier the stakes were carried at US$112.5 million against a market value of US$58.7 million.

Note 13 also shows how the JMMB carrying amount is built. PROVEN’s 20% share of JMMB’s net assets is US$73.6 million; the remaining US$28.6 million is goodwill paid at acquisition and still carried. The market valued the stake at US$42.3 million — US$31.3 million less than PROVEN’s share of JMMB’s own book value. In other words, the market prices JMMB below its book value, while PROVEN carries it above.

The direction of travel in 2026 makes the point sharper. JMMB’s profit for the year fell 56%, from US$22.4 million to US$9.7 million, and its market value fell 18%. PROVEN’s carrying amount rose by US$4.7 million, because its share of JMMB’s profit and other comprehensive income (US$6.3 million) exceeded the dividends received (US$1.0 million) and a currency adjustment (US$0.6 million). Management’s value in use moved from US$119.8 million to US$119.2 million, because two large assumptions changed in opposite directions: the terminal multiple was more than halved, from 15.8 times to 7.7 times, and the discount rate was cut from 17.38% to 14.42%.

Exhibit E02. JMMB and Access: value in use, carrying amount and market value at 31 March 2026. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 13; BATV analysis.

WHAT KPMG SAID

KPMG’s report contains two key audit matters — the areas the auditor judged most significant. The second, on page 73, is headed “Impairment of intangible assets and investment in associates”. It says the carrying value of the associates, US$117.6 million, “may not be recoverable due to changes in the business and economic environment in which the relevant investees operate”, and that the assessment requires “significant judgement in estimating and discounting future cash flows”. KPMG lists five procedures. It evaluated indicators of impairment, “considering market prices, the economic environment and business performance of each associate”. It involved its own valuation specialists. It compared management’s assumptions with external data and performed sensitivity analysis. It “compared the sum of the discounted cash flows to the investees’ market capitalisation, where applicable and our understanding of the market conditions, to assess the reasonableness of those cash flows”. And it assessed the adequacy of the group’s disclosures “about the key assumptions and the sensitivity of the impairment assessments to changes in key assumptions”.

Two observations follow. First, KPMG states that it compared the cash-flow valuation with the market capitalisation, but neither the audit report nor the notes say what the comparison showed or why the difference was judged reasonable. Auditors are not required to report the results of individual procedures in a key audit matter, so the gap is in what shareholders are told, not necessarily in what was done. Second, the final procedure refers to disclosures about “the sensitivity of the impairment assessments”. Note 13 gives the discount rate and terminal multiple for each associate, but no sensitivity analysis. IAS 36 does not strictly require a sensitivity disclosure for an associate tested as a single asset, but without one a reader cannot tell how far the US$17.0 million JMMB headroom, or the US$2.1 million Access headroom, would shrink if either assumption moved on its own. KPMG’s opinion is unqualified; the key audit matter records what was examined, not a reservation.

The comparison KPMG describes can be approximated from note 13 itself. Gross the 20% stake up to 100% of JMMB, and the three values on PROVEN’s books and on the market translate into familiar market ratios.

Table 3. What each valuation implies for JMMB as a whole

MeasureValue in useCarrying amountStock market
Value of PROVEN’s 20% stake (US$’000)119,155102,15242,297
Implied value of 100% of JMMB (US$’000)595,775510,760211,487
× JMMB adjusted net assets of US$367.8m1.62x1.39x0.58x
× JMMB profit for the year of US$9.7m61x52x22x
Same measure at 31 March 2025, × profit of US$22.4m27x22x12x

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 13 (summarised financial information of associates). All ratios are BATV calculations. JMMB’s adjusted net assets are net assets attributable to equity holders less non-controlling interests, as presented in note 13.

On these figures, management’s value in use places JMMB at 1.6 times its book value and 61 times its latest profit; the market places it at 0.6 times book and 22 times profit. The value in use is 2.8 times the market value. A year earlier, the same valuation represented 27 times JMMB’s profit; the profit has since halved and the valuation has not moved.

Exhibit E02A. KPMG’s stated comparison of discounted cash flows with market capitalisation, and what the annual report’s own figures imply. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, independent auditors’ report (page 73) and note 13; BATV analysis.

WHAT PROVEN PAID

PROVEN’s own accounts record how the stake was assembled. Its FY2020 annual report (note 14) states: “Effective December 27, 2018, Proven Holdings Limited acquired 326,277,325 shares or 20% shareholding in JMMB Group Limited”, and “acquired an additional 65,033,200 shares in the additional public offering on October 15, 2019, maintaining its 20% proportionate shareholding”. The seller of the first block was National Commercial Bank Jamaica, a subsidiary of NCB Financial Group, which announced the sale “at a price of $28.25 per share” — J$9.217 billion (NCB release to the JSE; The Gleaner, 30 December 2018). The second block came from JMMB’s October–November 2019 additional public offer (APO), priced at J$38.75 to the public and J$38.00 to existing shareholders and key investors. Neither PROVEN nor JMMB published PROVEN’s price; as an existing shareholder it qualified for J$38.00, a cost of J$2.471 billion (J$2.520 billion at J$38.75).

In US dollars, PROVEN’s cash flow statements show US$74.6 million spent on acquiring associates in FY2019 — of which US$0.57 million was a 20% stake in Dream Entertainment, leaving about US$74.0 million for JMMB — and a further US$17.3 million in FY2020, recorded as “acquisition of associate, net of dividends”. Adding back BATV’s estimate of the JMMB dividends received in FY2020 (about US$1.3 million) puts the cash cost of the 20% stake at about US$92–93 million.

Table 4. The cost of PROVEN’s JMMB stake

TrancheSharesJ$ per shareCost, J$mUS$m (PROVEN cash flows; BATV adj.)
27 Dec 2018, bought from NCB326,277,32528.259,21774.0
Oct–Nov 2019, JMMB APO (price inferred)65,033,20038.002,471~18.6
Total391,310,52529.87 avg11,688~92.7
Market value, 31 Mar 2026391,310,52617.14 implied6,70942.3

Sources: PROVEN Investments Limited 2020 Annual Report, note 14 and statement of cash flows (FY2019 acquisition of associates US$74,615k, of which Dream Entertainment US$570k; FY2020 US$17,324k net of dividends); NCB Financial Group release, 27 Dec 2018; JMMB APO notices; PROVEN 2026 Annual Report, note 13. The FY2020 US$ figure adds back BATV’s estimate of FY2020 JMMB dividends. The implied 2026 share price uses J$158.61 to US$1.

PROVEN financed the purchase with borrowing. Its annual reports from 2020 to 2024 describe a J$10.5 billion corporate bond issued through NCB Capital Markets “to assist with the acquisition of ordinary shares in JMMB Group Limited”, issued in two facilities, A and B, with a third, Facility C, available: Facility A, J$6.4 billion for ten years at 5% for years one to three, 6.5% for years four to six and 7.5% thereafter; Facility B, J$2.9 billion for six years at 6% for years one to three and 7.5% thereafter; and Facility C, J$1.2 billion at 6%, to be drawn for at most two years, which the reports up to FY2024 say had not been drawn. The 2021, 2022 and 2023 reports state that PROVEN “opted to repay [Facility B] early on March 11, 2021”. The 2026 report says Facility B “was repaid in 2023”, which conflicts with the 2021–2023 reports.

THE RESTATEMENT

This is not the first time the value of the stake has been revisited. In its FY2024 annual report (note 39, “Prior year adjustments”), PROVEN restated its previous accounts for two reasons: JMMB’s adoption of IFRS 17, the insurance contracts standard, which changed JMMB’s results; and “foreign currency adjustments arising on translation of the associates, together with those arising on intangible assets identified on acquisition”, whose recognition, the note says, “is required by IAS 21” — the standard on foreign exchange. The investment in associates at 31 March 2023 was cut from US$131.3 million to US$94.5 million, a reduction of US$36.8 million, and at 1 April 2022 by US$34.4 million. Equity attributable to owners at 31 March 2023 fell from US$131.6 million to US$94.9 million. FY2023’s share of associates’ profit went from US$8.5 million to US$1.2 million, and the loss attributable to shareholders from US$4.9 million to US$12.2 million. Of the US$36.8 million reduction at March 2023, about US$15.6 million went through the foreign exchange translation reserve — the IAS 21 correction — and about US$21.1 million reflected JMMB’s adoption of IFRS 17.

For JMMB alone, the carrying amount at 31 March 2023 went from US$114.6 million to US$79.3 million — within about US$0.5 million of the market value PROVEN disclosed that day, US$78.7 million. The foreign exchange point is visible in the earlier reports: from 2019 to 2023 the goodwill PROVEN carried on JMMB stayed at exactly US$35,964,000 each year, and the separate exchange line in the reconciliation was positive from 2021 to 2023, although the Jamaican dollar weakened over the period. In the 2026 report the goodwill stands at US$28.6 million.

Since the restatement, the gap has reopened. From March 2023 to March 2026 the carrying amount rose by US$22.9 million, to US$102.2 million, on PROVEN’s share of JMMB’s profits and other comprehensive income, net of dividends and exchange movements — including US$14.9 million of profit in FY2024, a contribution PROVEN’s FY2024 MD&A links to “a gain on investment in Sagicor Financial Company (SFC)”. Over the same three years the market value fell by US$36.4 million, to US$42.3 million. The FY2024 report’s own note on JMMB says the carrying amount “was determined to be higher than (2023: higher than) its recoverable amount and no impairment was identified” — as written, the opposite of its conclusion; the 2026 report words it correctly.

Table 5. PROVEN’s JMMB stake, year by year, US$’000

Year endCarrying, as first reportedCarrying, as restatedMarket valueShare of JMMB profitDividends received
Mar 201980,402 n/d1,308–
Mar 202095,917 111,03210,347~1,296*
Mar 2021122,587 88,78110,316~684*
Mar 2022116,67183,044†113,15414,455~2,191*
Mar 2023114,63379,26478,736762‡561
Mar 202496,832 65,82314,912551
Mar 202597,423 51,5684,479623
Mar 2026102,152 42,2971,949983
Total, FY2019–FY2026   58,528~6,889

Sources: PROVEN annual reports 2020–2026, notes on investment in associates; FY2024 report note 39. n/d: not disclosed. *BATV calculation from JMMB’s declared dividends (PROVEN’s statements for these years do not separate JMMB). †Restated balance at 1 April 2022. ‡FY2023 share of profit as restated (US$8,092k as first reported); FY2022 as re-presented in the FY2023 report (US$15,005k as first reported).

The table also shows how little of the profit PROVEN has booked from JMMB has reached it in cash. Since 2018 PROVEN has recognised US$58.5 million as its share of JMMB’s profits; it has received about US$6.9 million in dividends — roughly 12 cents of cash for each dollar of profit.

Exhibit E02B. PROVEN’s JMMB stake: carrying amount as first reported and as restated, against the market value disclosed by PROVEN, March 2020 to March 2026; profit recognised against dividends received. Sources: PROVEN annual reports 2020–2026; BATV analysis.

WHAT IT HAS RECEIVED

Since PROVEN bought in, JMMB has declared ten ordinary dividends to PROVEN’s year-end of March 2026, totalling J$2.74 a share. Applied to PROVEN’s shareholding at each record date, they come to about J$1.05 billion. In US dollars, PROVEN reports JMMB dividends of US$561,000 (FY2023, as restated), US$551,000 (FY2024), US$623,000 (FY2025) and US$983,000 (FY2026); for FY2020 to FY2022, when its statements combine dividends from all associates, BATV’s calculation gives about US$4.2 million. The total is about US$6.9 million. A further J$0.35 a share, about J$137 million, was paid in September 2026.

Table 6. Dividends received from JMMB, by PROVEN financial year

PROVEN yearJMMB dividends (J$/share)J$m receivedUS$’000Basis
FY2019none after purchase–– 
FY20200.28 (Jun 2019) + 0.21 (Nov 2019)173.5~1,296BATV calculation
FY20210.2597.8~684BATV calculation
FY20220.60 + 0.25332.6~2,191BATV calculation
FY20230.2597.8561PROVEN (restated)
FY20240.2597.8551PROVEN
FY20250.2597.8623PROVEN
FY20260.30 + 0.10156.5983PROVEN
Total to March 20262.741,054.0~6,889 

Sources: JMMB dividend declarations on the JSE and via Mayberry Investments; JMMB shareholder registers; PROVEN annual reports 2024–2026 (associate notes). J$ amounts are BATV calculations (dividend per share × PROVEN’s shares at each record date). PROVEN’s reported US$ figures for FY2023 and FY2024 are about 12% below a gross conversion of the J$ amounts; for FY2025 and FY2026 they agree to within 1%.

The cash return has been thin. The J$1.05 billion received is 9.0% of the J$11.7 billion paid, over a little more than seven years — roughly 1.2% to 1.3% a year. Over the same period, on the terms in PROVEN’s annual reports, the acquisition bond has accrued about J$3.2 billion in coupons: about J$2.8 billion on Facility A to March 2026 and about J$0.4 billion on Facility B until its early repayment in March 2021 (BATV estimates, assuming issue in January 2019; Facility C is excluded). The dividends have covered about a third of that.

Exhibit E02C. PROVEN’s JMMB stake in Jamaican dollars: paid, worth at 31 March 2026, dividends received, and estimated coupons on Facilities A and B of the acquisition bond. Sources as Tables 4 and 6; BATV analysis.

THE SCORECARD

Table 7. The JMMB investment, December 2018 to March 2026

MeasureJ$ (approx.)US$ (approx.)
Paid11.69bn92.7m
Market value at 31 March 20266.71bn42.3m
Dividends received to March 20261.05bn6.9m
Market value plus dividends7.76bn49.2m
Shortfall against cost, before financing costs(3.93bn) / −34%(43.5m) / −47%
Carrying amount in PROVEN’s accounts–102.2m
Management’s value in use–119.2m

BATV calculations from the sources in Tables 4 to 6. The US$ shortfall is larger than the J$ shortfall because the Jamaican dollar weakened from about J$125–140 to about J$159 to US$1 over the period.

Measured against the market, PROVEN’s JMMB investment has returned about 66 cents in the Jamaican dollar, and about 53 US cents in the US dollar, before the cost of the money borrowed to make it. Measured in PROVEN’s accounts, the same investment stands 10% above its US-dollar cost, and management’s value in use places it 29% above.

WHAT THE RULES ALLOW, AND THE CASE FOR PROVEN

None of this means the accounts break the rules. International Accounting Standard (IAS) 28 does not require an associate to be marked to market. It requires an impairment test when there is objective evidence of impairment — which includes “a significant or prolonged decline in the fair value of an investment in an equity instrument below its cost” — and IAS 36 then requires the carrying amount to be written down only if it exceeds the higher of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use. PROVEN’s recoverable amount rests on value in use. IFRS 13 measures the fair value of a quoted holding as price times quantity, without any premium for the size of the block, so any strategic value in a 20% stake and a board seat is, in practice, reflected only through value in use. IAS 28 allows value in use to be estimated either from the associate’s own cash flows or from the dividends and eventual sale proceeds the investor expects to receive; the annual report does not say which basis PROVEN used. A dividend-based valuation would have to be reconciled with a cash yield of under 1% on the carrying amount.

There is a fair case on PROVEN’s side. Many Jamaican financial shares have traded below book value for some time, and the JSE is thin, so a quoted price may understate what a 20% block would fetch in a negotiated sale. FY2026 may prove a weak year for JMMB’s earnings rather than a new normal. KPMG involved its own valuation specialists, tested the assumptions and issued a clean opinion. The point is not that the valuation is wrong; it is that the gap between PROVEN’s books and the market is now very large, rests on assumptions that moved sharply in a single year, and is disclosed without the sensitivity analysis or the result of the market comparison that would let shareholders judge it.

As an illustration only — not a measure the accounts require — if both associates were carried at their market value, the write-down would be about US$68 million, the year’s loss would be about US$73 million, and attributable equity would be about US$37 million rather than US$105 million.

3. The same year, twice

Last year’s annual report presented FY2025 like this: operating revenue, net, of US$51.5 million, other income of US$4.0 million, total income of US$55.5 million, operating expenses of US$55.2 million and an operating profit of US$289,000. This year’s report presents the same year with the same operating expenses of US$55.2 million, but total income of US$69.9 million and an operating profit of US$14.75 million.

The difference is exactly US$14,461,000 — the finance cost that now appears as a separate line beneath operating profit. In last year’s presentation it had been netted inside operating revenue. Net profit for FY2025 is unchanged at US$4.775 million in both reports. Nothing was earned that had not been earned before; the expense was moved to the other side of the line. Inside revenue, a further US$2.1 million was moved out of other income and into the named revenue lines.

Table 8. FY2025 as presented in two annual reports, US$’000

Line2025 annual report2026 annual reportDifference
Operating revenue, net of interest expense51,46568,051+16,586
Other income3,9981,873(2,125)
Total operating and other income55,46369,924+14,461
Total operating expenses(55,174)(55,174)–
Operating profit28914,750+14,461
Finance cost shown below operating profit–(14,461)(14,461)
Profit for the year4,7754,775–
Efficiency ratio, as published91.39%78.91%−12.5 pts

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2025 Annual Report (FY2025 income statement and Ten-Year Review); PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report (comparatives and Ten-Year Review); BATV analysis.

Two features of the change matter for shareholders. The first is disclosure. When a company reclassifies its comparative figures, International Accounting Standard (IAS) 1 asks it to disclose the nature, amount and reason for the reclassification. BATV found no such note in the 2026 statements. Last year’s note 39 dealt with a restatement of the cash flow statement; this year’s note 39 deals with the Roberts listing. The accounting policy that defines operating profit, note 3(p), says operating profit excludes “preference share dividend, share of profit of associates and income taxes”. It does not mention finance cost, and the US$17.4 million finance cost line is not analysed in any note.

The second is comparability. The Ten-Year Statistical Review now runs on two definitions in the same row: FY2025 and FY2026 exclude finance cost from operating profit, while FY2017 to FY2024 are left on the old basis. A reader scanning the row sees operating profit rise from a loss of US$1.1 million in FY2024 to US$14.8 million in FY2025 and US$10.6 million in FY2026. On a consistent basis the sequence is a loss of US$1.1 million, a profit of US$0.3 million and — on BATV’s re-computation — a loss of US$6.8 million. The MD&A tells readers that operating profit “declined to US$10.6 million from US$14.8 million”. Measured the way PROVEN measured it a year ago, it went from a small profit to a substantial loss.

There is a respectable case for the new layout. IFRS 18, the new presentation standard that takes effect for years beginning on or after 1 January 2027, will require companies to separate operating results from financing costs, and PROVEN’s own note 2 describes it. For a group that already reports interest on repurchase agreements and part of its notes-payable interest (US$5.0 million) inside net interest income, showing the remaining funding costs separately is arguably clearer, though it means the cost of notes now sits on both sides of the operating line. The objection is not to the destination. It is to arriving there without a sign-post, and to a ten-year table that changes its ruler halfway along.

Exhibit E03. Operating profit in the Ten-Year Statistical Review, with FY2025 and FY2026 restated by BATV to the old definition. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2025 and 2026 Annual Reports; BATV analysis.

4. What the report says, what the accounts show

An annual report is read by most shareholders from the front, and many never reach page 78, where the statements begin. The front pages of this one do not agree with each other, or with the back.

The Directors’ Report says equity attributable to owners “improved to US$105.4 million”. It fell, from US$108.7 million. The Chairman’s Report says shareholders’ equity “strengthened to US$122 million”. Total equity, including the Roberts minorities, fell from US$127.0 million to US$122.1 million, a decline the MD&A correctly describes as 3.8%. The Directors’ Report says total assets rose 4.5%; the MD&A and the balance sheet say 4.0%, to US$1.153 billion. The Investment Thesis page speaks of “over US$1.16 billion in assets”. The Directors’ Report says net interest income “remained flat”; the Chairman says it “increased”. It rose 0.6%.

Two errors go beyond wording. The governance section tells shareholders that directors’ emoluments for the year were US$418,000, “shown in note 29 of the financial statements on page 138”. Note 29, on page 138, shows directors’ fees of US$524,000 for FY2026; US$418,000 is the FY2025 comparative. The paragraph appears to have been carried forward from last year’s report without being updated. AGM Resolution 4 asks shareholders to approve “the amount shown in the Accounts” — the US$524,000, a 25% increase in a loss year. And the dividend per share is given as 0.11 US cents in the Ten-Year Review and 0.19 US cents in note 34. The arithmetic, US$845,000 divided by 801.7 million shares, gives 0.105 cents (Section 11).

Exhibit E04. Statements in the narrative sections of the annual report set against the audited figures. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

5. The price of the balance sheet

PROVEN’s MD&A is candid about the central problem: “The Group’s cost of wholesale funding remained a significant earnings constraint, with finance costs rising to US$17.4 million from US$14.5 million.” Add the US$8.5 million of interest expense already netted inside net interest income and the cost of funds charged to profit was US$25.9 million, against net interest income of US$30.9 million.

Table 9. Funding: notes payable and the cost of money, US$’000

LineFY2026FY2025Change
Structured notes212,939174,839+21.8%
Principal protected notes10,6508,691+22.5%
Long-term loan (note 19(iii))47,60640,510+17.5%
Other borrowings37,00949,694−25.5%
Notes payable, total308,204273,734+12.6%
Interest expense (inside net interest income)8,5418,967−4.8%
Finance cost (below operating profit)17,38614,461+20.2%
Cost of funds charged to profit25,92723,428+10.7%
Interest paid in cash (cash flow statement)3,2567,296−55.4%
Interest payable at year-end5,2851,671+216%

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, notes 19, 20, 27(a) and statement of cash flows. Totals of interest and percentage changes are BATV calculations.

The last two lines of Table 9 raise a question the report does not answer. The cash flow statement shows US$3.3 million of interest paid during the year, and the accrual for interest payable rose by US$3.6 million. It adds back the US$8.5 million of interest expense but not the US$17.4 million finance cost, which stays inside the loss in operating cash flow; how that cost was settled is not shown separately. The US$17.4 million finance cost line, one of the largest charges in the income statement, is not analysed in any note.

The group’s cash position moved the wrong way. Operating activities used US$61.6 million of cash. PROVEN bought US$1.28 billion of investment securities and sold US$1.22 billion, net purchases of US$59.1 million, and the portfolio grew US$62.4 million to US$500.8 million, mostly in corporate bonds; it borrowed a net US$34.5 million more in notes; and cash fell US$35.6 million to US$98.6 million.

The JMMB stake, examined in Section 2, shows the economics within a single year. It was financed in part by a J$10.5 billion bond arranged through NCB Capital Markets. Facility B was repaid early in March 2021 (Section 2); Facility A, J$6.4 billion, matures on 8 January 2029 and steps up to a fixed 7.5% after year six — which, on a ten-year term ending in January 2029, means the whole of FY2026. BATV estimates the annual coupon at about J$480 million, or roughly US$3.0 million at about J$160 to the US dollar. In FY2026 JMMB contributed US$1.9 million of equity-accounted profit and US$1.0 million of cash dividends. PROVEN also borrowed US$7.0 million from JMMB itself during the year, on two credit lines at 8.5% and 6.15%, and held US$9.8 million of deposits with it.

Exhibit E05. Cost of funds charged to profit, and the JMMB stake’s contribution against the estimated bond coupon, FY2026. The coupon is a BATV estimate. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

6. The bank in Cayman

Two short paragraphs, one in the MD&A and one in the capital management note, disclose a regulatory matter that deserves more space. During the year the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) completed prudential and anti-money laundering inspections of PROVEN Bank (Cayman) Limited. A remediation plan approved by the board was submitted to CIMA on 9 February 2026. Management concluded that no provision was needed, because the inspection reports “did not include any intention on the part of the Authority to levy any enforcement action” and any future action could not be reliably estimated. The report does not say what the inspections found.

In the same year, the Cayman bank’s regulatory capital fell sharply. Tier 1 capital dropped from US$81.5 million to US$66.8 million, a fall of US$14.7 million, entirely in retained earnings and reserves (US$45.7 million to US$31.0 million). With risk-weighted assets up 3.9%, the ratio of capital to risk-weighted assets fell from 24.89% to 19.64%. The bank remains above the minimum, but the minimum is itself stated inconsistently: the text of note 36(e) says CIMA requires 15.00%, while the table beneath it shows a 14.00% minimum for 2026 and 15.00% for 2025.

Table 10. Regulatory capital of the two banks, US$’000

MeasureCayman 2026Cayman 2025St Lucia 2026St Lucia 2025
Retained earnings and reserves31,03845,70732,29836,600
Total qualifying Tier 1 capital66,84081,50940,57544,877
Total regulatory capital66,84081,50937,85342,957
Risk-weighted assets340,281327,477172,188160,586
Capital to risk-weighted assets19.64%24.89%21.99%20.18%
Minimum shown in the table14.00%15.00%10.0%8.50%

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 36(e). For St Lucia the ratio shown is the Basel capital adequacy ratio (the separate Basel capital ratio was 23.57%).

The private banking segment, which contains both banks, reported a segment result of US$20.8 million for the year, so the fall in the Cayman bank’s reserves does not look like the product of trading losses. The report does not explain the fall. Reserves at the St Lucia bank fell by US$4.3 million as well, though its ratios rose. Shareholders are entitled to know how much capital was taken out of the regulated banks, in a year in which one of them was working through a regulator’s remediation plan, and what it was used for.

The deposit base changed character too. Due to customers rose 3.2% to US$621.4 million, but term deposits fell by US$128 million while non-interest-bearing accounts rose by US$134 million — cheaper funding, and one reason interest expense fell, but money that can leave more quickly.

Exhibit E06. PROVEN Bank (Cayman): Tier 1 capital and capital to risk-weighted assets. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 36(e); BATV analysis.

7. The loan book’s back pages

The MD&A devotes one clause to credit quality: “gross loans more than 90 days past due increased during the year.” The ageing table in note 36(b) shows by how much. Loans more than 90 days past due rose from US$10.9 million to US$19.4 million, an increase of 79%, to 9.3% of gross loans. Loans one to 30 days past due more than doubled, from US$17.1 million to US$36.9 million. The share of the book that was fully current fell from 84% to 70%, even though gross loans were broadly flat at US$208 million.

Table 11. Ageing of loans receivable, gross, US$’000

Bucket31 Mar 202631 Mar 2025Change
Current145,308178,737−18.7%
Past due 1–30 days36,88417,087+115.9%
Past due 31–60 days5,0562,625+92.6%
Past due 61–90 days1,5753,690−57.3%
Over 90 days19,40810,869+78.6%
Total gross loans208,231213,008−2.2%
Stage 3 (credit-impaired) loans16,791n/d 
Loss allowance on loans4,4414,005+10.9%

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, notes 6 and 36(b). n/d: not disclosed in the 2026 report. Percentage changes are BATV calculations.

Two details stand out. The group’s own accounting policy states that “a loan that is overdue for 90 days or more is considered credit-impaired”, which places it in Stage 3 of the expected credit loss (ECL) model. Yet US$4.1 million of the loans more than 90 days past due are shown in Stage 1, the category for loans with no significant increase in credit risk. And the US$16.8 million of Stage 3 loans carry a provision of US$3.5 million, a cover of 20.7%, which implies management expects substantial recoveries, presumably from collateral. The year’s charge for loan impairment was only US$359,000, while total past-due loans rose by more than four-fifths, from US$34.3 million to US$62.9 million. The mortgage book, US$150 million of the total, is mostly long-dated, and collateral may well justify the provisioning, but the report does not show the collateral values that would let a reader judge.

Exhibit E07. Ageing of gross loans, 31 March 2025 and 2026, with Stage 3 loans and over-90-day loans held in Stage 1. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, note 36(b); BATV analysis.

8. Sold, not yet collected

The brightest line in the year is property. Sales almost tripled, from US$10.2 million to US$28.6 million, as units were handed over at developments including Sol Harbour in Ocho Rios, and the division moved from a gross loss of US$1.0 million to a gross profit of US$3.4 million. Investment property rose to US$35.8 million, helped by US$3.9 million of transfers from development and a US$1.6 million fair value gain. Property development in progress fell to US$47.1 million from US$52.0 million as completed stock was released into earnings.

Two numbers temper the picture. The gross margin on property was 12.0% — before overheads and before the cost of the money tied up in the projects; the real estate segment carried US$2.6 million of finance cost. And note 7 discloses that receivables from the sale of properties stood at US$22.9 million at year-end, equal to 80% of the year’s property sales (BATV ratio). About US$17 million was collected after the year-end. The revenue policy explains why: a unit counts as sold when it is habitable, deposits are received, and a bank’s letter of undertaking is in hand (or 60% of a cash price has been paid), titles are available and the Real Estate Board discharge is received. Revenue can be booked well before the cash is collected.

Table 12. Property division, US$’000

LineFY2026FY2025
Property sales28,59010,194
Property expenses(25,164)(11,157)
Gross profit/(loss) on property3,426(963)
Investment property35,77930,231
Property development in progress47,07951,997
Receivables from sale of properties at year-end22,900n/d
Rental income2,1741,676

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, income statement and notes 7, 9 and 11.

Exhibit E08. Property sales, gross profit, unpaid receivables and development in progress. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

9. The manager’s share in a loss year

PROVEN Group Limited has no employees. It is run by PROVEN Management Limited under an investment management agreement, and note 1 of the audited statements states that “the Company is controlled by MPS Holdings Limited by virtue of the rights” attached to 10,000 Manager’s Preference Shares (MPS). BATV examined that structure in Controlled by Ten Thousand Shares. The manager is paid in two ways: a management fee of 2% of the average consolidated net asset value, and a performance dividend of 25% of group profits above an annual earnings hurdle, paid to MPS Holding.

In FY2026 the performance dividend was nil. With a group loss there were no profits above the hurdle, and the formula behaved as written. That is to its credit. The management fee did not fall. It rose from US$1.79 million to US$2.28 million (US$2.08 million paid and US$199,000 accrued), an increase of 27.5%, in a year in which attributable equity fell 3.1% and total equity fell 3.8%.

Table 13. Payments to the manager against results for shareholders, US$’000

YearManagement feePerformance dividendTotal to managerProfit to ownersDividend to owners
FY20242,9491,6494,59812,3155,008
FY20251,7902602,0502,5032,406
FY20262,283–2,283(4,820)845
Three years7,0221,9098,9319,9988,259

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2025 and 2026 Annual Reports (related party notes, income statements, Ten-Year Review). FY2024 fee as given in note 33(b) of the 2025 report, which elsewhere gives US$2,727,000. Totals are BATV calculations.

Over the three years FY2024 to FY2026, the manager and its vehicle received US$8.9 million against US$10.0 million of profit attributable to ordinary shareholders. In FY2026 alone the fee was 2.7 times the US$845,000 dividend paid to them. The fee base still cannot be checked from the published figures. Two per cent of average attributable equity gives US$2.14 million; two per cent of average total equity gives US$2.49 million; the fee charged implies a base of about US$114 million (BATV calculations). General consumption tax, which note 1 says is added “if applicable”, may account for part of the difference. Note 22 still defines the performance hurdle by reference to a “hurdle rate” it does not state.

The leadership pages show changes at the manager. Paul Simpson, founder of Cornerstone and deputy chairman of Barita Investments Limited — the second-largest name on PROVEN’s top-ten shareholder list — is now listed as a director of PML, as is Jason Chambers.

Exhibit E09. Management fee and performance dividend against profit attributable to ordinary shareholders, FY2024 to FY2026. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2025 and 2026 Annual Reports; BATV analysis.

10. The report against its own rules

The governance section sets out its own tests, and the rest of the annual report can be read against them.

  • Independence. A director is independent only if he or she “has not served on the Board for more than nine years from the date of their first election”. Jeffrey Gellineau, with 13 years on the board and chair of the Audit, Risk and Compliance Committee (ARCC), and Rhory McNamara, with 15, are both described as independent.
  • Board size. The text says the board “is currently comprised of five directors, of which three are independent”. The list beside it names six directors: five described as independent non-executives, including Mr McNamara, who resigned as chairman on 24 April 2026, and one executive.
  • Audit committee. The governance pages describe the committee as two independent non-executive directors and one executive director, meeting five times. The committee’s own report lists four members, including the executive director, and six meetings on six named dates.
  • The executive on the audit committee. Garfield Sinclair, co-founder and director of PML and the board’s one executive director, sits on the committee that reviews the financial statements, and signed those statements on behalf of the board.
  • Nomination. The committee charter says members are appointed “on the recommendation of the Nomination Committee of the Board”. No Nomination Committee is described anywhere in the report.
  • Pay. The governance text cites last year’s directors’ emoluments (Section 4).

There was also a change at the top. Mr McNamara resigned as chairman with effect from 24 April 2026, after the year-end. Mark Myers, Managing Director of Restaurants of Jamaica, joined the board in February 2026, became chairman with effect from 28 April 2026, and signs the Chairman’s Report, as is customary for the incumbent. The board evaluation, conducted on 7 November 2025, concluded that the board and its committees “continued to operate effectively”.

Exhibit E10. Governance tests stated in the annual report, set against what the report also shows. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

11. Three numbers for one dividend

PROVEN paid one dividend in FY2026: an interim on 2 July 2025, which AGM Resolution 2 asks shareholders to declare final, with “no further dividend” for the year. Owners received US$845,000. The minority shareholders of Roberts Manufacturing received US$1,004,000 in the same year — more cash than went to PROVEN’s own shareholders.

The per-share figure is given three ways. The Ten-Year Review says 0.11 US cents. Note 34 says 0.19 cents. Dividing US$845,000 by 801.7 million shares gives 0.105 cents. The FY2025 comparatives are no more consistent: note 34 gives 0.31 cents, while the Ten-Year Review gives 0.54 cents — a figure that matches the group’s total dividends of US$4.3 million including the Roberts minorities, not the US$2.4 million paid to PROVEN’s shareholders. Last year’s annual report described the FY2025 dividends paid as US$4.315 million; this year’s Ten-Year Review shows US$2.406 million for the same year. The dividend yield fell from 4.72% to 1.08%.

Table 14. Dividends, US$’000 unless stated

MeasureFY2026FY2025
Dividend to PROVEN’s ordinary shareholders8452,406
Dividend to Roberts minority shareholders1,0041,909
Total dividends paid by the group1,8494,315
Per share, Ten-Year Review (US cents)0.110.54
Per share, note 34 (US cents)0.190.31
Per share, BATV arithmetic (US cents)0.1050.300
Dividend yield, Ten-Year Review1.08%4.72%

Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report, statement of changes in equity, note 34 and Ten-Year Review; BATV analysis.

Exhibit E11. Dividend per share as stated in the Ten-Year Review and note 34, against the arithmetic, and where the dividend cash went. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report; BATV analysis.

12. The company’s side

A fair reading must give weight to what went right and to the explanations PROVEN offers.

  • Property turned. The division moved from a gross loss to a US$3.4 million gross profit on US$28.6 million of sales, and about US$17 million of the year-end receivables has since been collected. A US$2.6 million receivable from Massy Barbados, outstanding since the Roberts pension transfer, was settled in July 2026.
  • Investment gains improved. Net fair value and realised gains rose to US$4.8 million from US$1.3 million.
  • The regulated subsidiaries met their capital requirements throughout the year, according to the report, and the St Lucia bank’s Basel capital adequacy ratio rose to 21.99%. CIMA’s reports did not indicate enforcement action.
  • Funding got cheaper at the margin. Interest expense inside net interest income fell 4.8% while non-interest-bearing deposits grew, and management names refinancing as its first priority.
  • The manager’s performance dividend was nil in a loss year, as the formula intends.
  • The structure is being simplified. Roberts Manufacturing listed on the Barbados Stock Exchange on 29 May 2026. PROVEN’s stake fell from 50.5% to 38.81% and Roberts is now an associate, which removes a loss-making manufacturer from the consolidated operating lines.
  • The presentation change has a basis. IFRS 18 will require finance costs to be shown outside operating profit from 2027.
  • The audit opinion is clean. KPMG issued an unqualified opinion, with key audit matters on expected credit losses and on the impairment of intangibles and associates — the two areas this report also examines.

Management’s own assessment is frank. The MD&A says the result “underscores the need to reduce the Group’s funding burden, improve returns from deployed capital and convert operating improvements into stronger bottom-line performance”. The year also included Hurricane Melissa, which hit the western parishes of Jamaica, and the group records relief work and staff support in the annual report.

Exhibit E12. What the year delivered, on the company’s own figures. Source: PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report.

13. Eight questions for the board

Shareholders attending the AGM on 5 November 2026, or voting by proxy, may wish to put these questions to the board and to the manager, whose members the board requires to attend.

1.  KPMG says it compared the discounted cash flows supporting the associate valuations with market capitalisation, where applicable. For JMMB, what did that comparison show, and on what basis was a value in use 2.8 times the market value judged reasonable?

2.  Is JMMB’s value in use based on JMMB’s own cash flows or on the dividends PROVEN expects to receive, and why has the carrying amount risen by US$22.9 million since the FY2024 restatement while the market value fell by US$36.4 million?

3.  Why was finance cost moved out of operating revenue, where is the reclassification of the FY2025 comparatives disclosed, and why were FY2017 to FY2024 in the Ten-Year Review left on the old basis?

4.  What does the US$17.4 million finance cost consist of, and how was it settled in cash, given that the cash flow statement shows only US$3.3 million of interest paid?

5.  What did CIMA’s prudential and anti-money laundering inspections find, what will the remediation cost, and why did PROVEN Bank (Cayman)’s Tier 1 capital fall by US$14.7 million?

6.  Why are US$4.1 million of loans more than 90 days past due held in Stage 1, when the group’s policy treats such loans as credit-impaired?

7.  On what base was the 2% management fee of US$2.283 million calculated, and why did it rise 27.5% in a year in which equity fell?

8.  Which per-share dividend figure is correct, why does the governance section state last year’s directors’ emoluments, and do directors with 13 and 15 years’ service meet the board’s own nine-year independence test?

Exhibit E13. Eight questions for the board of PROVEN Group Limited. Source: BATV analysis of the 2026 Annual Report.

The verdict

PROVEN’s diversified model is real, and parts of it worked this year: property turned, investment gains recovered, the banks gathered deposits. But the largest judgement in the accounts is the value of JMMB. PROVEN paid about J$11.7 billion for its stake; the market valued it at about J$6.7 billion at the year-end; the accounts carry it at US$102.2 million, 2.4 times the market value, on assumptions that changed sharply in a single year. The auditor examined that judgement and says it compared the cash-flow valuations with market capitalisation, where applicable, without saying what it found. The year’s other central fact is that the group’s operating businesses do not earn enough to pay for the money that funds them, and the annual report does not make that fact easy to see. It changes the definition of operating profit without a note, presents a ten-year table on two bases, describes falling equity as improving, carries its associates well above their market value at each of the last two year-ends, and gives shareholders two different per-share figures for one small dividend, neither of which matches the arithmetic.

BATV does not allege that any of these breaches the accounting rules, though IAS 1 calls for a note on the reclassification; KPMG’s opinion is clean. Taken together they describe an annual report that asks its readers to do more work than they should have to. The board has four weeks before the AGM to answer the questions above. Until it does, the most reliable pages of the 2026 annual report are the ones at the back.

Exhibit E14. BATV’s verdict on the 2026 annual report, area by area. Source: BATV analysis.

Right of response

In line with BATV’s editorial policy for its special reports, PROVEN Group Limited, its directors and PROVEN Management Limited were not contacted before publication, and publication was not delayed to seek comment. This report is built on public information and expert analysis. Any of them is free to challenge any point or conclusion. Where they do, BATV will publish a feature response article carrying their clarification. Contact: info@batvja.com.

Sources and methodology

Primary source. PROVEN Group Limited 2026 Annual Report (176 pages), including the audited consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 March 2026, approved by the board and signed by KPMG on 28 August 2026. Comparisons with the prior year’s presentation use the PROVEN Group Limited 2025 Annual Report.

Sources for the JMMB investment history (Section 2). NCB Financial Group, investor release on the sale of JMMB shares, 27 December 2018 (jamstockex.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/12/Investor-Release-NCBFG-Sale-by-NCBJ-of-JMMB-Shares-December-27-2018.pdf); The Gleaner, “Proven buys large stake in JMMB, as NCB exits”, 30 December 2018, and “Proven selling Access shares pending JMMB offer”, 25 September 2019; Jamaica Observer, 12 October 2019; JMMB Group top-ten shareholder lists at 31 March 2019, 31 March 2021 and 31 March 2026; JMMB APO announcements and JSE basis-of-allotment notice, October–November 2019; PROVEN Investments Limited quarterly report, June 2020; PROVEN Investments Limited / PROVEN Group Limited annual reports for 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024 (notes on investment in associates, notes payable, statements of cash flows, and the FY2024 note 39 on prior year adjustments);  JMMB Group dividend declarations on the JSE and via Mayberry Investments, 2019–2026; Bank of Jamaica exchange rates as reported by the Jamaica Observer near each date used.

Reported figures. All figures attributed to PROVEN are taken from the annual report as published, in US dollars. Where narrative sections and the audited statements differ, the audited statements are treated as authoritative.

BATV-derived figures. The following are BATV calculations and are labelled as such in the text: the FY2026 operating result on the old definition (US$10.635m less US$17.386m = a loss of US$6.751m); the carrying-versus-market gap on associates (US$67.99m) and its ratio to attributable equity (64.5%); the illustrative mark-to-market equity (about US$37m); PROVEN’s market capitalisation at the FY2026 average price (about US$80m); the implied valuation multiples for JMMB in Table 3; the cost of the JMMB stake in J$ and US$ (Table 4); the year-by-year dividend estimates for FY2020–FY2022 (Tables 5 and 6); the acquisition bond coupon total since 2019 (about J$3.2bn: Facility A, J$6.4bn at 5% for three years, 6.5% for three years and 7.5% from January 2025 to March 2026, about J$2.8bn; Facility B, J$2.9bn at 6% from January 2019 to its repayment on 11 March 2021, about J$0.4bn; assuming issue in January 2019 and excluding Facility C); the US$ cost of the stake (PROVEN’s cash flows with an estimated US$1.3m of FY2020 dividends added back); cumulative profit recognised (US$58.5m, on the latest reported figure for each year; the FY2024 restatement also reduced retained earnings at 1 April 2022 by US$17.4m, so on a fully restated basis cumulative profit would be lower and cash cover higher); the JMMB scorecard (Table 7); the acquisition bond (Facility A) coupon estimate for FY2026 (J$6.4bn × 7.5% at about J$160 to US$1, assuming a ten-year term from January 2019 to the stated January 2029 maturity); the cost of funds total (US$25.9m); the property receivable ratio (80%); implied fee bases; three-year totals; percentage changes; and the per-share dividend arithmetic.

Caveats. BATV’s finding that no reclassification note exists is based on a full reading of the published report; if PROVEN has disclosed the reclassification elsewhere, BATV will say so. Market values of the associates are those disclosed by PROVEN at 31 March 2026 and have since moved. The JMMB coupon figures are estimates. The price PROVEN paid in the November 2019 APO is inferred: PROVEN confirmed it participated, and its holding rose by 20.01% of the new shares, but no notice states its price; at the public price of J$38.75 the total cost would be J$11.74bn rather than J$11.69bn. The J$0.21 dividend (record date 25 November 2019) assumes the APO shares were registered by the 25 November 2019 record date (if not, FY2020 dividends would be about J$13.7m lower). For FY2020–FY2022 PROVEN’s statements do not separate JMMB dividends from those of other associates, and the US$ figures for those years are BATV calculations; for FY2023–FY2026 PROVEN’s reported JMMB figures are used. The FY2020 cash outflow for associates is reported net of dividends, and the split between the APO purchase and dividends is a BATV estimate. PROVEN’s annual report gives its JMMB holding as 391,310,526 shares; JMMB’s register gives 391,310,525. The J$ market value uses J$158.61 to US$1 (30 March 2026). The reasons for the fall in PROVEN Bank (Cayman)’s reserves are not stated in the report and BATV draws no conclusion beyond the question put to the board. Value in use is a permitted measure under IAS 36; the mark-to-market illustration is not a figure the accounting standards require. Earlier BATV coverage of PROVEN referred to in this report: Five Flags, One Engine (FY2026 geographic and segment results), Nine Point Four Million, None of It Sold (Q1 FY2027 and the Roberts divestment) and Controlled by Ten Thousand Shares (the manager’s fee structure).

Abbreviations. AGM: annual general meeting. ARCC: Audit, Risk and Compliance Committee. CIMA: Cayman Islands Monetary Authority. ECL: expected credit loss. IAS: International Accounting Standard. IFRS: International Financial Reporting Standards. JSE: Jamaica Stock Exchange. MD&A: Management’s Discussion and Analysis. MPS: Manager’s Preference Shares. NCI: non-controlling interest. PML: PROVEN Management Limited.

ABOUT BUSINESS ACCESS TELEVISION (BATV)

Business Access Television (BATV) is a Caribbean business media platform delivering financial journalism, market analysis and corporate storytelling across the region. BATV is part of the Dawgen Media group and an affiliate of Dawgen Global, an independent integrated multidisciplinary professional services firm headquartered in Kingston, Jamaica. Editorial enquiries: editorial@batvja.com. Visit: www.batvja.com.

For feedback: contact the BATV Editorial Division at: info@batvja.com

This Post Has 0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back To Top
Search