PwC Fined for Serious Audit Failings Over Wyelands Bank Collapse

By BATV News

One of the world’s largest accounting firms, PwC, has been slapped with a hefty £4.5 million fine over its audit of Wyelands Bank, once owned by steel magnate Sanjeev Gupta. The Financial Reporting Council (FRC) found that PwC’s audit of the bank’s 2019 financial statements fell significantly below professional standards, highlighting serious lapses in risk assessment and failure to address glaring red flags related to related-party transactions.

The Fall of Wyelands Bank

Wyelands Bank, originally founded in 1980, was acquired in 2016 by Sanjeev Gupta and became part of his expansive GFG Alliance group. Touted as a visionary behind the revival of UK steel, Gupta’s reputation has since suffered as regulatory scrutiny intensified around his financial empire.

Following revelations that Wyelands Bank had funnelled significant amounts of depositors’ funds into other Gupta-linked businesses, regulators grew increasingly alarmed. In an unprecedented move, the Bank of England ordered Wyelands to return funds to its retail savers — effectively dismantling the bank’s operations. It was a damning indictment of the lender’s governance and risk practices, which ultimately led to its liquidation.

PwC’s Audit Under the Microscope

The FRC’s investigation uncovered six separate breaches in PwC’s audit, particularly around understanding the bank’s lending exposures and its entanglements with GFG Alliance firms. Among the most critical findings were:

• Inadequate risk assessments of the bank’s loan book
• Failure to properly investigate related-party transactions
• Lack of professional skepticism regarding the bank’s operational model
• Insufficient consideration of warnings issued to the bank by the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA)

Jonathan Hinchliffe, the PwC partner who led the audit, was personally fined £55,000 — later reduced to £33,412 in recognition of his cooperation. PwC’s total fine was also lowered to £2.9 million from the original £4.5 million due to what the FRC described as “exceptional cooperation” during the investigation.

Regulatory Backlash and Broader Implications

Claudia Mortimore, FRC’s deputy executive counsel, underscored the broader significance of the audit failings. “Auditors must understand the business they are auditing — especially where ownership changes and operations evolve significantly,” she said. “In this case, risks linked to the GFG Alliance were not sufficiently addressed, despite clear regulatory warnings.”

The scandal is one of several embroiling Gupta and the GFG Alliance. The group is currently the subject of fraud and money laundering investigations by authorities, casting further doubt on its business practices. The collapse of Greensill Capital, a key financier of GFG, in 2021 has only deepened the financial web surrounding Gupta’s empire. Greensill had once employed former UK Prime Minister David Cameron as an adviser.

Adding to the accountability trail, former Wyelands CEO Mark Hunter was fined nearly £120,000 in 2024 by the PRA for regulatory breaches during his tenure.

PwC Responds

In response to the FRC’s ruling, a spokesperson for PwC issued a statement acknowledging the failings:

“We acknowledge and apologize that aspects of this audit fell short of the required standards. Since 2019, we have made significant investments in improving our audit practices. Audit quality remains our top priority.”

The firm has reportedly implemented a multi-year overhaul aimed at enhancing audit oversight and compliance.

Conclusion

The downfall of Wyelands Bank and the subsequent penalties against PwC serve as a stark reminder of the critical role auditors play in maintaining the integrity of the financial system. With regulators tightening their grip and corporate accountability under growing public scrutiny, firms like PwC face increased pressure to not only meet — but exceed — professional expectations.

For feedback: contact the BATV Editorial Division at: info@batvja.com